Saturday, June 20, 2026
Alistair Crooke update on MoA with Iran
https://www.youtube.com/live/LQz66eU-pgQ?si=WPFbO2MfWKQeAKcM
Friday, June 19, 2026
US-Iran meeting in Switzerland postponed
https://sonar21.com/us-and-iran-will-not-meet-in-switzerland-israel-derails-the-negotiation/
Thursday, June 18, 2026
Text of the MoU with Nima and Larry Johnson
https://www.youtube.com/live/pDVwed9QDRk?si=hkvxeZELIza1f-4D
Richard Pape and Patrick Henningsen with Danny Haiphong
https://www.youtube.com/live/wMZpfLQx0zk?si=BspIia-6nGRJfet1
Wednesday, June 17, 2026
Pepe Escobar with Judge Napolitanoon the current state of MoU with Iran
https://www.youtube.com/live/hPaW0kHj7-0?si=c4pusxMvtXiahHU7
Tuesday, June 16, 2026
Alastair Crooke on the current pause in Iran war
https://www.youtube.com/live/eiEH9Lww67A?si=D4b0kOTFF76J_8tD
More here https://strategic-culture.su/news/2026/06/15/post-iran-war-end-era-not-decline-but-as-trigger-abrupt-change/
Sunday, June 14, 2026
Another peace deal?
Short take from Tita Parsi https://youtu.be/HjGp9vQnYnQ?si=5UsSUxYW6JpSCaKK
https://sonar21.com/friday-catch-up-the-iranians-are-being-bamboozled-again/
https://www.news.com.au/world/north-america/us-politics/us-politics-iran-war-live-updates-iran-says-deal-with-us-wont-be-signed-sunday/live-coverage/8b0e8fdb068b9042e8a454c40787398a
Liability problems AI overviews
https://www.resultsense.com/insights/2026-06-11-google-ai-overview-liability-munich-ruling/
Friday, June 12, 2026
Thursday, June 11, 2026
War is back, from Daniel Davis conversation with Alistair Crooke
https://www.youtube.com/live/pEHDc-UYi0U?si=laK0CYCsyknqsycw
Wednesday, June 10, 2026
Yves Smith on the current war on Iran
https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/06/iran-war-us-launches-new-attacks-on-iran-using-bogus-pretext-with-iran-retaliating-swiftly-global-economy-destroying-long-conflict-looks-baked-in.html
Tuesday, June 09, 2026
A long article on Yahya Sinwar
who changed middle east https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/08/12/yahya-sinwar-profile-hamas-gaza-war-israel (it may take a few arrempts to open the page).
MENTIONED HERE https://www.youtube.com/live/LMoMQ3E0_JU?si=PrbQYyAEAEnJuMUt
Monday, June 08, 2026
Iran sends missiles to Israel with Mario Nawfal and Larry Johnson
https://www.youtube.com/live/C5_7c9mmWkI?si=7HlldXK-WpUJ1bPx
Friday, June 05, 2026
Economic attrition game?
According toThe Duran it may be another four months https://youtu.be/vq62yMGdAiQ?si=gBuK9ARx8H0Pz0ic
Two updates from Judge Napolitano
colonel Wilkerson says that it is likely that Iran has nukes https://www.youtube.com/live/QV5jW_KRyKA?si=djszyg2JiTSqMB-H
Douglas Macgregor on the general situation with Iran https://www.youtube.com/live/vOjEQTXT9kQ?si=rwC-jd86TjOZphqh
Thursday, June 04, 2026
Wednesday, June 03, 2026
Long discussion from Mario Newfal with Malcom Vance and Aquilar
lot of intereting details from milirary experts https://www.youtube.com/live/DNBm2pmuXc4?si=9q0natIn4GJFOeWe
Tuesday, June 02, 2026
Hua Bin on indianization of the west
https://huabinoliver.substack.com/p/when-argument-becomes-opium-amartya
A crucial escalation? Iran Abandons Talks & Threatens to Retaliate Against Israel
https://youtu.be/e03waQsmDkY?si=-gVRM665Zuai7keX
Monday, June 01, 2026
Yves Smith daily update suggests no peace in sight in the war on Iran
But i doubt whether Trump will go for a big attack. it may slow burn escalation https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/06/iran-war-iran-rejects-trump-claims-that-deal-is-near-as-us-counterproductively-toughens-terms-hotter-tit-for-tat-strikes-threaten-ceasefire-what-if-trump-continues-to-stall-when-hitting-energy-clif.html
US to merge with IDF?
From Colonel Karen Kwiatowski https://www.youtube.com/live/GzE2NkgQKa4?si=SuUBa-9qUujaiBqo
From Robert Barnes https://www.youtube.com/live/LPdeT4kf0HU?si=ToK0ueSr8JpsCZ2V
Saturday, May 30, 2026
Rapid change since the previous video
BREAKING: TRUMP NEW MILITARY OPERATION IN HORMUZ. But there is no confirmation of the initial news from other sorces so far. https://www.youtube.com/live/NdTYQxuGW_w?si=krdU2P9BCj4-FDni
Anthony Aguilar on possible developments in Hormuz
A strategic blunder https://www.youtube.com/live/-B78m8F_2SQ?si=HDccpsJY2hIEZhmP
Thursday, May 28, 2026
Update by Alastair Crooke via Danny Haiphong:Iran Effect
https://www.youtube.com/live/f0VoPB6mncU?si=I1FUvIuNr49Zwemd
Wednesday, May 27, 2026
Scott Ritter:Why Bother to Negotiate With Trump?
https://www.youtube.com/live/7u8xEdmI_hQ?si=6uLYUls_ucNC6dK4
Saturday, May 23, 2026
Friday, May 22, 2026
Colonel Doug Macgregor overall picture
of the conflicts in Iran and Ukraine https://youtu.be/UVuGUf0paEw?si=Fn1h2PPKC29MgntA
Tuesday, May 19, 2026
Two on the escalation of Ukraine Russia conflict
Mark Sleboda https://youtu.be/hWsb25VYodI?si=ExamwcBq59PIDfp7
Stanislav Krapivnik https://www.youtube.com/live/q5l_vCHU4xI?si=75cX_7I_lDYia20a
Larry Johnson discusses Israel explosion, Iran and Ukraine
https://www.youtube.com/live/kIlLKqPzY8Y?si=Y9nUXeTkeIkKDXBq
Scott Ritter on the current state of war from Iran to Ukraine
https://www.youtube.com/live/Y0W2vpjIQoM?si=5Q41b-mvph9zb8yn
Sunday, May 17, 2026
Photographs of mathematicians
https://old.maa.org/press/periodicals/convergence/whos-that-mathematician-paul-r-halmos-collection-introduction-page-1
Michael Hudson on US designs on Iran
one problem seems to be that Iran still has US trained economists https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/05/michael-hudson-us-designs-on-iran-and-the-trump-xi-summit.html
ond problem seems to be that Iran (like many other countries) still has US trained economists. see also https://sociology.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/faculty/fourcade/AJSII.pdf
Saturday, May 16, 2026
Book review by JohnLancaster on money laundering books
https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v48/n09/john-lanchester/squillions
Friday, May 15, 2026
Civilization at the Crossroads with Alastair Crooke (Full Interview)
https://youtu.be/MGnJEb4sXwM?si=gLcSq3FjfhMX3MPE
Colonel Larry Wilkerson discusses what empires do
MacArthur, there is no substitute for victory.
Go to hell, Doug. That's not what empires do. Empires simply hold the
world at bay and fulfill their monetary, economic, and other interests, mercenary
interests, and that's all you can expect. And you fuel the complex that keeps those wars going on because that's what you want to do. You want to be constantly at war, but you don't want anyone to defeat you in the traditional sense So, it's not really a metric you can use to judge the empire by winning or losing wars. It's no longer consequential in the scheme of things for Rome.
But the empire has not achieved any of its stated goals.
Well, it has achieved a few. It has gotten a barrier of conflict. That's what I'm calling it now. A barrier of conflict.
What's that?
From the Arctic Ocean all the way a barrier of conflict. Not barrier to conflict of conflict. Conflict all the way from north of Manask in the Arctic Ocean where we're doing things the American people and our media aren't reporting don't know anything about. We're all the way through the Baltic where we're still agitating around all the way through Ukraine. all the way down to Georgia where we're still trying to overthrow that government. Other governments in the Caucasus are now being impacted by that too, down to Iran, the biggest and latest chapter in this axis of crisis and disturbance. And all this is designed to put a wall up against further Chinese and Russian now infiltration into Eastern Western Europe and ultimately across the Atlantic and into the North American continent.
That's what it's all about. From https://www.youtube.com/live/Ai48FpArr8Q?si=eToagy_XiXWWJb_n
Nima with Colonel Anthony Aguilar discusses Lebanon and other things
https://www.youtube.com/live/4m5yv6gKM4Q?si=JB0-sluLQtU4JqMS
Thursday, May 14, 2026
India again in this Janta Ka Report and timesaxis
https://youtu.be/D-yXi1geTiI?si=XXF-ROT4QfDKa8y6
https://youtu.be/7ZMrwGTMdm8?si=FiaqXmjE8hTSfL6Z
mlfd today from Bhadrakumar https://www.indianpunchline.com/indias-quasi-alliance-with-israel-and-uae-wont-have-happy-ending/
Scott Ritter discusses the current situation in Iran and also discusses India at the end
https://www.youtube.com/live/euTjsj7OonU?si=POqldmnh-fF0S4zu
I am not optimistic about India because I don't think India there India hasn't made a strategic decision yet. Remember India was in
1:01:301 hour, 1 minute, 30 secondsIsrael making common cause with the Israelis right before this war started.
1:01:351 hour, 1 minute, 35 secondsum that doesn't sit well and India is problematic when it comes to China and Pakistan. I mean Pakistan
1:01:431 hour, 1 minute, 43 secondsI think Pakistan is one of the great superstars of this crisis. The the leadership that Pakistan has shown the maturity that Pakistan has shown the
1:01:511 hour, 1 minute, 51 secondsability of Pakistan to um work with the United States, with China, with Russia, with Iran um and others to to create the
1:01:581 hour, 1 minute, 58 secondspotential for a diplomatic solution. If ever there was, you know, an entity that deserved the Nobel Peace Prize, if if this if this
1:02:081 hour, 2 minutes, 8 secondscan if if if this conflict can be brought to an end, I think the Pakistani leadership deserves collectively the
1:02:151 hour, 2 minutes, 15 secondsNobel Peace Prize for the role they played in making peace possible. Um because it's amazing what they've done.
1:02:211 hour, 2 minutes, 21 secondsUh superb diplomacy. Um but you know, India is problematic. I mean, India is a problem child. It's big. It's powerful.
1:02:301 hour, 2 minutes, 30 secondsUm but they don't know where they want to be in the world and as long as India is indecisive like that. Now maybe this
1:02:371 hour, 2 minutes, 37 secondsmeeting will you know be the beginning of India's you know transition to being serious about bricks
1:02:451 hour, 2 minutes, 45 secondsbut right now India is not serious about bricks not serious at all. and he is more serious about uh you know G20
1:02:521 hour, 2 minutes, 52 secondsviability and uh you know hoping against hope to get an invitation into the the G7 um which will never
1:03:001 hour, 3 minuteshappen. Um you know India's also continues to lobby for relevance at the security council and they feel they need the United States uh support to uh to
1:03:091 hour, 3 minutes, 9 secondsget that. So India is is is putting far too much weight on a relationship with the United States that's no longer
1:03:161 hour, 3 minutes, 16 secondsglobally relevant. Um I mean the bottom line is India's future must be with repairing relations with China and um
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=euTjsj7OonU
Wednesday, May 13, 2026
An interesting discussion with Robert Barnes and Krapivnik
Trump is America's new Golden Calf https://youtu.be/eD3U_MtTkk4?si=SmzLqDwIxvBIt0lV
Tuesday, May 12, 2026
MoA:War On Iran: – Saudis Blame Israel – Neocon Grandee Concedes Defeat
https://www.moonofalabama.org/2026/05/war-on-iran-saudis-blame-israel-neocon-grandee-concedes-defeat.html
Sunday, May 10, 2026
Professor Marsndindescribes the latest naval encounter near Oersian gulf
early in the video https://www.youtube.com/live/RDvZv4mZTlg?si=LWYOE3K1wcQSJNGX
Thursday, May 07, 2026
Laith Marouf discusses Lebanon and the fraud between UAE and Saudi Arabia
From 24 minutes onwards, Laith Marouf describes the origin of UAE, Qatar and how the ruling families are branches of the Saudi Royal family which is leading to the current fauds https://www.youtube.com/live/gGc-ym4-gpQ?si=6Xh8hW8rUhv_lOKE
A quick search does not agree with Marouf's assertion. From Quora:
Key points and clarifications
“Blood relation” in Gulf monarchies usually means close patrilineal descent or first/second-degree kinship. The major ruling houses (Al Saud, Al Thani, Al Nahyan, Al Khalifa, Al Maktoum) each descend from different tribal lineages; they are distinct dynasties rather than offshoots of a single immediate family.
Intermarriage: political marriages between ruling families and elite clans are common. These create marital ties (in‑laws, cousins by marriage) but do not imply close direct blood descent between the sovereigns unless specifically documented. For example, members of UAE ruling families sometimes intermarry with other Gulf royals, producing bilateral kin connections at the extended-family level.
Distant tribal ancestry: many Gulf dynasties share broad Arabian tribal origins going back centuries. Those shared roots explain cultural and historical affinity but do not constitute close genealogical kinship among current rulers.
Practical implication: there is no simple close-blood relationship (father/son, brothers, first cousins) tying the current heads of Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Abu Dhabi (UAE) and Bahrain together. They lead separate dynasties with occasional marital ties and distant tribal commonality. From https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-blood-relation-between-the-leaders-of-Qatar-Saudi-Arabia-Abu-Dhabi-U-A-E-and-Bahrain
Tuesday, May 05, 2026
Sunday, May 03, 2026
Two Russian commenters with US experience discuss current wars
https://youtu.be/4RVRTaPZSfg?si=WdHvoNLwo6zNqMyv
Saturday, May 02, 2026
From C.Wright Mills
The Power Elite (1956) describes the relationships among the political, military, and economic elites, noting that they share a common world view; that power rests in the centralization of authority within the elites of American society.[61][page needed] The centralization of authority is made up of the following components: a "military metaphysic", in other words a military definition of reality; "class identity", recognizing themselves as separate from and superior to the rest of society; "interchangeability" (they move within and between the three institutional structures and hold interlocking positions of power therein); cooperation/socialization, in other words, socialization of prospective new members is done based on how well they "clone" themselves socially after already established elites. Mills's view on the power elite is that they represent their own interest, which include maintaining a "permanent war economy" to control the ebbs and flow of American Capitalism and the masking of "a manipulative social and political order through the mass media."[59][page needed] Additionally, this work can be described as "an exploration of rational-legal bureaucratic authority and its effects on the wielders and subjects of this power."[48] President Dwight D. Eisenhower referenced Mills and this book in his farewell address of 1961. He warned about the dangers of a "military-industrial complex" as he had slowed the push for increased military defense in his time as president for two terms. This idea of a "military-industrial complex" is a reference to Mills' writing in The Power Elite, showing what influence this book had on certain powerful figures.[62]
From the Wikipedia article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C._Wright_Mills
Another by Frank Elwell https://web.archive.org/web/20220519122501/http://www.faculty.rsu.edu/users/f/felwell/www/Theorists/Mills/SocMills.htm
Are the elites the same everywhere? From a post in Dialogue works.
Lawrence Wilkerson after about 28 minutes:
six years ago I guess now, maybe a little longer, a report well done participating in by some Iranians in Iran at the University of Iran. Um, and the report showed how much money oil sales generated for Iran on a fiscal year basis in US dollars. And then it showed how much the IRGC took out of that fabulous amount of money. They were taking about one quarter of the Iranian budget, most of it generated from oil sales,oil and gas. And the implication was strong when you just
did simple things like analyze the number of people in the RGC leadership and the amount of money being and essentially taken away from the Iranian government which could have been used for social programs for food you know any any number of things that would have benefited the Iranian people was going to the RGC and then when you read further in the analysis it wasn't going to the rank and file of the RGC. was going to the leadership. So that is a problem within the chemistry if you
will I suspect of Iran.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y5Ij0cWArw0&t=3292s
Friday, May 01, 2026
Patrick Henningsen with Danny Haiphong
https://www.youtube.com/live/jlIJefVCjAI?si=LQcuhuDDcG6cIPwJ
They're using the US military as a kind of ad hoc kind of you know
18:1218 minutes, 12 secondsmodular mercenary force that's really kind of been commandeered by a foreign government if you think
18:2018 minutes, 20 secondsabout it. Um we're talking about the state of Israel.
Thursday, April 30, 2026
Alastair Crooke comments on the current state of the Iran confrontation
https://www.youtube.com/live/o-P_gUeA5Zo?si=rwH9MpKFVYXYxWcr
Tuesday, April 28, 2026
The Duran: How Iran and Ukraine Exposed America's Limits w/ Garland Nixon
https://youtu.be/QIkzOy-jeqE?si=HSune9QWlaXofASg
Robert Inlakesh on the background for the current Iran conflict
https://youtu.be/Xs2DH0YW6sw?si=_wmQ9n-UlrFJKMki
Monday, April 27, 2026
Brian Berletic update
His theory is that US is in contril not Israel https://youtu.be/j8UVRmjJB5o?si=c6UBgAkHm_OtNEL5
Saturday, April 25, 2026
Robert Barnes on Trump’s options with Daniel Davies
https://youtu.be/zia-lulyoxA?si=x1-eB_kMy21eVzuE
Thursday, April 23, 2026
Wednesday, April 22, 2026
Update from Janta Ka Reporter:Trump extends ceasefire indefinitely as Iran refuses to join peace talks
https://youtu.be/1g7-i_0MIjg?si=JuWR3Do_9BS33ocD
An update from Colonel Macgregor:No Peace - U.S. Prepares for 'Total War' Against Iran
https://youtu.be/1AZPNUaXJ-k?si=c_k6NNDgfrPtq4-O
Tuesday, April 21, 2026
Scott Ritter on the nuclear possibilities in Iran war
https://www.youtube.com/live/QRkC8xniXkQ?si=E0g4AzrE9QiKVT9a
And others https://www.moonofalabama.org/2026/04/war-on-iran-signs-point-to-escalation.html#comments
Scott Ritter with Stanislav Krapivnik https://youtu.be/9DOT41hsMZM?si=ZJM1AgW8zO4I5rrk
Monday, April 20, 2026
Yves Smith updates on Trump’s mental state from yesterday
https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/04/iran-war-mad-king-trump-strait-of-hormuz-closed.html
Saturday, April 18, 2026
Thursday, April 16, 2026
Colonel Larry Wilkerson on the grim possibilties
with Rachel Blevins https://youtu.be/AanatE0W6Mw?si=NnEA5fdVV_boJuA5
Wednesday, April 15, 2026
NamitArora on Indian caste system
https://youtu.be/pvYqORZaxe4
My comment:It is good as far as it goes. There seem to be some issues that are neglected. One of these is the internal life of the groups involved. As an example I would point out a relatively recent concept; the so called American exceptionalism. This has been mentioned by various American politicians and seems to be prevalent among many Americans. I think that there are similar things in caste groups. One of these is mentioned by Johannes Bronkhorst in ‘How the Brahmins won’. Through a period of reflection when they lost power, the Brahmins focussed on their internal life and much of their literature during that period was focussed on their internal life. They developed attitudes which helped them with loss of power and attitudes which helped them cope and keep their feeling of superiority(?’). This led to them being exampled to others too, probably resulting in some sort of sanskritisation. Thesecond point neglected is the the development of internal discipline; for example in the oral transmission of vedas over centuries and the corresponding attitudes that resulted in the particular group. Even if they did not understand what was transmitted, the discipline and ritual of repetition with exact pronounciation must have had long term effects. The third is adoptibility which is mentioned system palatable to others. to some extent , adopting the local gods goddesses beliefs in to their own system and making their
The status of the US blockade of the Straits of Torbuz from Janta Ka Reprter
https://youtu.be/z16NNth4A4Y
see also https://youtu.be/XazEaPWjuvM
Tuesday, April 14, 2026
Alastair Crooke at Judging Freedom
situation fluid but this is the general trend in the sites that i follw https://www.youtube.com/live/LJaEyk9eeV8?si=YbV-Zbifq2EQnsEz
https://youtu.be/WJ5W8or1C1U?si=O2_jRjM-qtD74CiX
Sunday, April 12, 2026
The American game according to Richard Medhurst
This may explain why Modi chose US-Israel side https://youtu.be/0nt1CgQsgpI
discussion at MoA in the comments https://www.moonofalabama.org/2026/04/war-on-iran-loser-tries-setting-terms-the-strange-idea-of-blockading-blockaders.html
Saturday, April 11, 2026
US-Iran negotiations in the hands of two billionaire politicians
says Bhadrakumar https://www.indianpunchline.com/us-iran-negotiations-are-safe-in-the-hands-of-two-billionaire-politicians/
Russia too seems to have used a billionaire in some of gheir negotiating teams
Thursday, April 09, 2026
Tucker Carlson with Alastair Crooke
Crppke comes after the first hour https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5aKtwQByXw
Wednesday, April 08, 2026
Tuesday, April 07, 2026
Scott Ritter on saving the colonel and future possibilities
future possibilities after 27 minutes seems plausible. https://www.youtube.com/live/WLZquiY3rug?si=hM9lhs_vZrhdOJc9
Monday, April 06, 2026
Not a day without some dangerous nonsense
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/apr/05/trump-iran-threats-politician-reactions
Saturday, April 04, 2026
Yves Smith daily report on Iran war
https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/04/iran-war-disaster-in-iran-as-multiple-aircraft-downed-pilot-missing-iran-pounds-israel-hard-after-trump-asks-for-48-hour-ceasefire-concerns-in-military-and-congress-over-purge-of-war-cautious-offi.html
Ramarao Kanneganti on the tendency of systems to preserve themselves
Ramarao Kanneganti Facebook post in Telugu. https://www.facebook.com/ramarao The translation from the comments:
Any system, whether social, political, or economic, has a tendency to preserve itself. If it does not, it disappears. Over time, systems evolve rules that stabilize and protect them, sometimes deliberately, often gradually.
These rules come from many places. History, culture, religion, habit, and circumstance. Some reflect real constraints. Traffic must be regulated. Contracts must be enforceable. Others arise in particular contexts and then persist long after those contexts have changed.
But once rules are in place, they acquire authority. They stop appearing as choices and begin to feel like facts about the world.
As Thomas Hobbes argued in Leviathan, the alternative to a system of rules is not freedom but disorder. Life becomes “nasty, brutish, and short”. Without a shared framework, social life becomes unstable. So we accept rules, even imperfect ones, because they allow coordination.
You can see this in ordinary life. In the United States, the tax system is complex and often opaque, yet widely followed because it sustains the functioning of the state. In India, the government can be frustrating, but it enables coordination across a large and diverse society. In both cases, the system persists not because it is elegant, but because it works well enough.
So far, this is about order.
But rules also shape outcomes. Over time, they distribute advantage.
Some groups benefit more than others. This is not always planned with major foresight. It often emerges gradually. But once patterns of advantage appear, those who benefit tend to reinforce them. Rules harden and begin to feel natural.
Anatole France captured this clearly: the law, in its equality, forbids both rich and poor from sleeping under bridges. The rule is the same. The effect is not. There is formal equality, but not practical equality.
At this point, we need a deeper explanation for why such arrangements endure.
This is where Antonio Gramsci is useful. His idea of hegemony suggests that systems do not survive only because they are enforced. They survive because they are accepted. Over time, people come to see the system not as one arrangement among many, but as the natural order of things.
What began as a set of rules becomes 'common sense'.
This helps explain why inequity can persist for long periods. People do not simply endure it. They interpret it in ways that make it acceptable or at least understandable. Systems provide explanations, and those explanations matter.
For example, why do people accept inequality? In the United States, for example, large differences in income and wealth are often explained through ideas of merit and effort. These explanations are not entirely false, but they do not capture the full picture either. Yet they persist because they provide a coherent way to understand outcomes within the system.
All of this together made the system hegemonic. It did not rely only on enforcement. It was reproduced through everyday practice and shared understanding.
This does not make it just. It explains why it endured.
So systems persist through a combination of structure, culture, and belief.
However, this persistence has limits.
To understand those limits, Jean-Jacques Rousseau is helpful. In The Social Contract, he argues that a system is legitimate only if it reflects a shared will. Authority is not justified merely by maintaining order. It must be seen as representing a collective interest.
Inequity, by itself, does not immediately invalidate a system. It can grow for a long time while the system continues to function. People adapt, justify, or work around it.
But as inequity grows, its effects become more visible. The gap between the formal rules and their actual consequences becomes harder to ignore. Explanations that once seemed plausible begin to feel strained. At the same time, opportunities for movement within the system may narrow. When these conditions combine, people begin to question whether the system still reflects a shared interest. Laws and institutions may continue to operate, but they are no longer experienced as belonging to everyone. They appear to serve particular groups. In these changes, education plays a major role. Literature too. Revolutions usually are the result.
This is how the social contract weakens. Not suddenly, but through a gradual loss of belief.
To be clear, Inequity alone does not automatically lead to breakdown. Some unequal systems persist because they maintain legitimacy, adapt to pressure, or prevent coordination among those who are disadvantaged.
Inequity becomes destabilizing when it is widely visible, when it cannot be convincingly justified, and when people feel that effort within the system does not lead to meaningful change. Under those conditions, acceptance gives way to skepticism, and skepticism to resistance.
So:
Systems create rules to stabilize themselves.
Rules shape outcomes and distribute advantage.
Over time, systems become embedded in culture and accepted as natural.
Stability depends on material conditions, shared belief, and the ability to adapt.
When inequity grows and legitimacy weakens, that stability becomes fragile.
Where does this leave us in terms of political ideas?
Liberalism focuses on fairness at the level of individuals. John Rawls’s veil of ignorance asks us to design a world without knowing where we will end up in it.
Conservatism focuses on stability. Change should be gradual and tested. Stability itself is a hard-won achievement.
Both are trying to manage the same tension. Fairness and stability.
There is another perspective as well: The tension between openness and protection. Openness to markets, migration, and change on one side, and a desire to preserve stability, identity, and continuity on the other.
But beneath both lies the deeper issue we have been tracing. A system can function with a considerable degree of imperfection. It can tolerate complexity, inefficiency, and some level of unfairness. What it cannot sustain indefinitely is a broad loss of belief in its legitimacy.
Reducing inequity, then, is not only a moral concern. It is also a structural one. It helps maintain the sense that the system reflects a shared interest and that participation within it remains meaningful.
Without that, institutions may continue to operate and rules may still be followed. But the underlying contract weakens, and the system gradually loses its coherence.
What we are witnessing in the US, and broadly around the world is this phenomenon of loss of legitimacy. Conspiracy theories spread through social media accelerate the trend. The fundamental challenge is inequity and inequality
A different discussion from Graeber institute: Starvation ahead
https://www.youtube.com/live/8s0ss4nCR7g?si=A2ZFkRLDmHsN3OOY
another https://youtu.be/F5ySyr-hQ3U?si=TGkhUGy34tRUxd-O
Friday, April 03, 2026
From Robert Kagan, husband of Victoria Newland
America is now a rogue superpower'https://archive.md/aZrz9
commentary by Simplicius https://simplicius76.substack.com/p/sanctity-lost-even-neocon-pantheon
Karbala, Mohyal Brahmins*, and the Spirit Driving Iran’s Defiance
https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=10234041695812852&set=a.10202364730428515
see also Rahul Singh Gautam's comment:
In contrast to its organic emergence in Arabia, Islam’s arrival in Persia in the 7th century CE was a cataclysmic event. The Arab conquests (633–651 CE) toppled the Sassanid Empire, one of the ancient world’s great powers, and introduced Islam to a civilization with millennia of philosophical, literary, and religious tradition. Unlike Arabia, where Islam built upon existing cultural frameworks, in Persia, it dismantled them.
Zoroastrianism, the dominant religion of pre-Islamic Iran, had shaped Persian ethics through its triad of “good thoughts, good words, good deeds”. Its dualistic cosmology, emphasizing the struggle between good (Ahura Mazda) and evil (Ahriman), provided a moral and metaphysical foundation for Persian society. The Achaemenid (550–330 BCE) and Sassanid (224–651 CE) empires, renowned for their administrative genius, architectural splendor, and religious tolerance, represented a civilizational high point. Yet, under Islamic rule, these legacies were marginalized, labeled as jahiliyyah, the age of ignorance, a term that dismissed pre-Islamic Persian achievements as barbaric.
Iran’s disillusionment is rooted in a collective memory of what might have been. Unlike the Arab world, which sees Islam as the culmination of its historical trajectory, Iran has never stopped imagining an alternative path. The revival of Zoroastrianism, though practiced by fewer than 25,000 Iranians, symbolizes this longing for a pre-Islamic identity as a rejection of Islamic hegemony.
No comparable civilizational rupture exists in the Arab world. Even Arab secularism operates within an Islamic cultural grammar. From Ba’athism to post–Arab Spring political experiments, Islam remains the unquestioned civilizational backdrop. For Arabs, Islam is not experienced as an imposition but as an origin story. For Iranians, it remains a foreign layer, internalized, institutionalized, yet never fully reconciled with a deeper sense of self.
This is why Islam functions differently in Iran than anywhere else in the Muslim world. In Arab societies, Islam anchors identity. In Iran, it constrains it. What the Arab world regards as continuity, Iran experiences as displacement. And until that civilizational tension is resolved, Islam in Iran will remain not a source of belonging, but a reminder of what was lost
Thursday, April 02, 2026
Craig Murray visits Venezuela
" The claims that RodrÃguez wants this, still more that she engineered this, are nuts." https://orinocotribune.com/the-weight-on-delcy-rodriguez/
"I have now spent a total of six weeks in the country over two trips, talking to students, diplomats, union leaders, commune activists and people inside the government – and a great many barmen. What I have seen and heard convinces me of one thing above all: Delcy RodrÃguez is not a traitor. She is a socialist doing the only thing possible to her in this impossible situation — buying time for the Bolivarian Revolution to survive."
Larry Johnson and colonel Macgregor on Iran
long interview with both by Mario Nawfal https://www.youtube.com/live/oNr0zoT_vDM?si=3nZvYfjil07-ITFg
Tuesday, March 31, 2026
Yves Smith daily round up on Iran
https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/03/iran-war-trump-threatens-destruction-of-iran-electric-generation-and-oil-wells-even-as-wsj-reports-temporary-taco-on-trying-to-force-open-strait-of-hormuz.html
Larry Johnson discusses Boots on the Ground scenario
https://www.youtube.com/live/BSezLaNm8xY?si=gAEYlVBtYW8C-jm8
Monday, March 30, 2026
Larry Johnson update on Trump and Middle East
https://sonar21.com/a-baron-of-lies-turns-the-world-upside-down-and-loses/
Sunday, March 29, 2026
Daily report from Yves Smith on Iran war
long war ahead https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/03/iran-war-more-signs-of-a-long-conflict-and-resulting-severe-economic-damage.html
Update from Alastair Crooke
https://www.unz.com/acrooke/irans-audacious-strategic-moves-declared-missile-dominance-over-the-occupied-territories-a-warning-of-nuclear-deterrence/
https://www.youtube.com/live/VzfqtjAIkJA?si=wFDqehMENTaZmQOa
Saturday, March 28, 2026
Daily summary of Iran war from Yves Smith
https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/03/iran-war-more-escalation-us-strikes-iran-steel-plants-israel-sends-third-missile-at-iran-nuclear-plant-yemen-joins-war.html
Tuesday, March 24, 2026
Alastair Crooke update
https://www.youtube.com/live/Cg_IFXiCNLM?si=fQpf-8rqXDpBDSrN
https://www.youtube.com/live/hyDn1OPqvTk?si=KMaNuF-l92KYWDtO with Kevork Almassian of Syrianaanalysis
Saturday, March 21, 2026
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)