Sunday, September 09, 2012

Louis Malle on film and dance in Madras

From the Wikipedia article on Louis Malle
"In 1968 Malle visited India and made a seven part documentary series L’Inde fantôme: Reflexions sur un voyage and a documentary filmCalcutta, which was released in cinemas.[1] Concentrating on real India, its rituals and festivities, Malle fell afoul of the Indian government, which disliked his portrayal of the country, in its fascination with the pre-modern, and consequently banned the BBC from filming in India for several years.[2] Malle later claimed his documentary on India was his favorite film[2]" 
Some of the commentary in the film seems politically incorrect and some over the top but he seems unafraid to explore and spell out his reactions. There are many uploads, but the following version has English subtitles (the same person also uploaded the parts on caste):
Part 1 Part 2 Part 3

Duncan Green informs on development courses

in the post:
"Back to school time: CGD celebrates the start of term with a pile of online syllabuses on different aspects of development while it’s boss Nancy Birdsall is even taking 3 months off to do some teaching. The Guardian asks ‘why study development?’ Meanwhile uberblogger Tyler Cowen is running an online development economics course with Alex Tabarrok [h/t Charles Kenny]. And here’s Chris Blattman’s development syllabus."

Saturday, September 08, 2012

Songs and dances in campaigns

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4JB_Mqm1tV8&list=UUwZe40roJacf6xx9dRLuEeg&index=18&feature=plcp
The description "While helping a Dalit community build houses as part of a volunteer trip April 29 - May 6 2011, we found time for some of the equally important things in life: having fun, and DANCING! The kids in Chevuru LOVE to dance. Our volunteer group also loved this song, so Emily Bucherati, one of the volunteers, compiled footage of us dancing with the kids and created into a dance video to go along with it."
After seeing this, I wondered what happened tp 'praja natya mandali; the Andhra wing of IPTA. They seem to be operating still and have a few videos on YouTube. in http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KlLSmwvr1PY they seem to be cooperating with a non-communist group. Sumangala Damodaran on IPTA songs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W6Lr1llA6Ko She has an album too.

Friday, September 07, 2012

Similar songs in different languages, 1949

From Patanga , Shamshad Begum and Lata Mangeshkar

 Pyar ke jahan ki nirali sarkar




From Vazhkai (from 11:35, Rajeshwari, Bhagavati?)
R. Sudarshanam, the MD of Vazhaki seems to have followed closely some Hindi tunes(from Badi Behan, Mela) in this film, but the above films are from the same year. According to http://www.thehindu.com/arts/cinema/article3509383.ece
an earlier tune of C.Ramachandra influenced one in Vazhkai.

Kuffir on the efficiency of caste

mostly about economic efficiency in Caste is not efficient or capable. The thrust of the post comes from a paper of Abhijit Banerjee and Kaivan Munshi
How efficiently is Capital Allocated? Evidence from Knitted Garment Industry in Tirpur
From Kuffir's account ( the last paragraph is quote from the paper):
To sum up, roughly, the Gounders employ more capital than the Outsiders but dont get better results than them. Caste isn't efficient.

But the Gounders can start garment units more easily, get easier access to capital and labour, rely on better co-operation from local authorities, and can stick around longer (even if they are not as efficient as the Outsiders) because of what the researchers call the 'community effect' (or plain old caste loyalty, in other words). But despite all those advantages:
 In our data the Outsiders seem to outperform the Gounders. This is easiest to see by comparing the Gounders and Outsiders who have more than 5 years of experience. The Outsiders in this category own less capital stock than the corresponding Gounders. Yet they produce significantly more. Moreover, the growth rate of output is higher for the Outsiders with more than 5 years of experience compared with the corresponding Gounders, which rules out the possibility that the Gounders are trading off current productivity for future growth. Finally, these Gounders use more capital per unit of output and own more capital stock at every level of experience: everything else being the same, this should give them a higher growth rate. The slower growth of the Gounders is therefore in spite of this additional advantage. 


Micronutrient fortifications and supplements

Following up on an article in New York Times Easier Than Taking Vitamins which bemoans the delay in the spread of the use of Sprinkles, I came across the interesting article Taken with a Grain of Salt? Micronutrient Fortification in South Asia

"Abstract: This paper reviews the research on fortification of food in the context of South Asia, with an emphasis on avenues for future research in economics and policy. We argue that while the efficacy of fortified foods in controlled settings is well established, more research is needed to evaluate the take-up and effectiveness of fortified foods distributed through standard channels. In addition, we argue that more research is needed to understand the determinants of long-term demand for fortified foods."
Some sample passages about the problems of policies and distribution in India:
"Political support in India for micronutrient interventions and fortification, specifically, has been slow and inconsistent.......
 Some states, such as Tamil Nadu, have already made progress on the distribution of DFS, but these recent developments signal headway towards resolving one nation-wide obstacle in the use of fortified foods: the absence of a directive from the Central Government on the regulation of fortified foods and their use. Without such a directive, NGOs working in this area often find it difficult to motivate local governments to allocate money towards fortifying food in schools
......

There are important target groups not reached through schools. For example, there is evidence that children
younger than school age are more likely to benefit from nutrition programs (Adelman, Gilligan,and Lehrer, 2008). In India, 70% of children under the age of five and 56% of ever-married women age 15-49 are anemic, making reaching these at-risk groups imperative.
......

Another way to provide fortification is through hospital or clinic distribution, although this might be a more natural channel for supplementation. In theory, the advantage to this strategy is that there is existing infrastructure to promote health awareness and possibly better targeting of households at-risk of micronutrient deficiencies. However, the performance of health clinics across India does not inspire confidence in either of these tasks. Health providers are absent on average 40% of the time and absence rates are higher in poor places (Chaudhury et al., 2006), where households are also more likely to be micronutrient deficient. Despite public health mandates to provide iron and folic acid syrup to pregnant women and vitamin A supplements to  children, these treatments do not reach all of their intended beneficiaries: in India, 65% of pregnant women were given or purchased iron and folic acid syrup, but only 23% took it for more than 90 days, and only 25% of children receive regular vitamin A supplements
(International Institution for Population Sciences, 2007). This is likely due in part to lack of demand for clinic services, these facilities being closed unpredictably and to the health facilities not being adequately stocked even when they are open. Research on how to improve the health care sector’s performance and how to increase awareness among households on when to visit health clinics and what care to expect, are important open questions. There is little evidence on this, although one notable exception suggests that contracting to non-governmental organizations, where payment and contract renewal depend on achieving health targets, such as how many children receive vitamin A supplements, improved performance (Bhushan et al.,2007)."

A government document of India also says that the targets for the tenth five year plan were not reached.

Thursday, September 06, 2012

A discussion in ft.com/alphaville

Recently most commented article in ft.com/alphaville Towards a steady-state economy/
Tom_ comments at 8:17 PM and 8:38 PM on September 4 seem interesting to me.
P.S. Related Is US Economic Growth Over?

The Guardian on ENCODE project

From Breakthrough study overturns theory of 'junk DNA' in genome :
"For years, the vast stretches of DNA between our 20,000 or so protein-coding genes – more than 98% of the genetic sequence inside each of our cells – was written off as "junk" DNA. Already falling out of favour in recent years, this concept will now, with Encode's work, be consigned to the history books.
Encode is the largest single update to the data from the human genomesince its final draft was published in 2003 and the first systematic attempt to work out what the DNA outside protein-coding genes does. The researchers found that it is far from useless: within these regions they have identified more than 10,000 new "genes" that code for components that control how the more familiar protein-coding genes work.
.....................

This means that the individual differences in people's diseases can be more effectively targeted for treatment. "Diseases have been defined by the medical profession observing symptoms," says Dr Tim Hubbard of the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute in Cambridge. "[But] we know, for example, that breast cancer is not one disease but there's multiple types of breast cancer with all sorts of different mechanistic processes going wrong.
"A given drug only works in about a third of the people you give it to, but you don't know which third. A lot of that is related to genomics, so if you knew the relationship between a person's genome and which drugs work for them and which ones they shouldn't take because it gives them side effects, that would improve medicine.""

Wednesday, September 05, 2012

A multilingual song from Aadmi (1939)

According to some this was Shantaram's best film. Even the acerebic Baburao Patel praised it(page 21)
More about the film here.

Tuesday, September 04, 2012

Chandralekha and others

After watching a few traditional dances in the fifties, I was turned off for the following sort of resaons;.it seems that several others including many professional dancers had similar doubts. From an article by Sunil Kothari:
"Chandralekha raised several questions:
  • Why have classical Indian dances become insular and unresponsive to the dramatic social, historical, scientific, human changes that have occurred in the world during the past thirty years?
  • What makes them resistant to contemporary progressive values?
  • Why have attempts not been encouraged to explore the power and strength of the forms and their links with the martial arts?"
It seems that Chandralekha and several others like from Mrinalini Sarabhai, Mallika Sarabhai did some thing about it ( I came across these names in the book of essays "Bharatanatyam : A Reader" edited by Davesh Soneji).
Here are two articles on Chandralekha, her obituary by Reginald Massey and her profile by Ashish Khokar. Sadananda Menon who spent thirty years in her house recounts his first meeting with her and other impressions.

Obama at Reddit

here via Razib's pinboard link to NY Times article Left Alone by Its Owner, Reddit Soars

Saturday, September 01, 2012

Mera naam chun chun choo

via New York Times and Ksenia Sigalova version in Dances on the Footpath
Information about the Mayuri Dance Group here and here.
P.S. Interview with some members of the group, mostly in Hindi

Indira Gandhi's emergency

Lot of good people supported Indira Gandhi's emergency rule. P.N.Dhar was one of them. I was curious about his role since he was the husband of Sheila Dhar who wrote an excellent and irreverent book about Indian music. It turned out that P.N. Dhar wrote a book about the emergency and there is a readable review by Paul R.Brass. Excerpts from the review:
"With regard to the declaration of the Emergency regime, Dhar artfully displaces blame for it away from Mrs. Gandhi’s own willfulness to the opposition and the people of India as a whole. The “cause” of the Emergency, in his account, was not the Allahabad High Court judgment invalidating Mrs.Gandhi’s election and her determination to avoid its inevitable consequences of loss of power by establishing an authoritarian regime and changing the relevant laws and whole sections of the Constitution of India as well. The cause, rather, “was a systemic failure”: the “democratic system” had been breaking down for years. The most blatant manifestations of its breakdown, Dhar argues, occurred in the immediately preceding years in the mass movements launched by Jayaprakash Narain (JP) and other opposition leaders against the Congress and Mrs. Gandhi’s leadership. Dhar glides from his general “causal analysis” to a complete reversion of blame for the establishment of the Emergency regime from Mrs. Gandhi’s specific and well-known decisions to JP’s leadership, which led the opposition parties “to convert JP’s call into a confrontationist movement which eventually ended in the Emergency” (p. 248). He ignores completely the fact that the mass movements led by JP had petered out many months before the decision of the Allahabad High Court, though that decision raised the hopes of its leaders and the fears of Mrs. Gandhi that it could once again be revived during her moment of truth."
Brass goes on to analyze the ruling classes in India. Interestingly many of the bureaucrats of that time went on to win Padma Vibhshan and such awards.The emergency was lifted in 1977, apparently without consulting Sanjay Gandhi. Guha says in the above mentioned article of 2000 "The Emergency lasted for 20 months. In January 1977, to everyone's surprise, Mrs. Gandhi called elections. There are competing explanations as Jo why she did this. Back then, it was widely believed that Mrs. Gandhi's own trusted advisors in the Research and Analysis Wing had predicted a hands-down victory for her. In his book, P. N. Dhar speculates that Mrs. Gandhi wanted once more to hear the accolade of the people, to seek through the campaign trail the admiration and reverence that had so readily come her way in 1971. A third possibility is that Mrs. Gandhi was shamed by the example of Pakistan, then enjoying one of its all-too-rare periods of democratic rule." 
There is longer and more nuanced account in Guha's 2007 book "India after Gandhi" (Here Gandhi is Mahatma Gandhi). It may be a combination of the above reasons together with Indira Gandhi's sensitivity to opinions of India's friends in UK and USA  and with some of whom Indira was in correspondence much of the time.

Ellie Cole wins gold at Paralympics

Ellie Cole from The Melbourne suburb of Frankston won gold medal at the 2012 Paralympics in London
"Ellie Cole was similarly dominant in women's S9 100m backstroke final, also setting a new Oceania best time. She finished 1.65 seconds up on Britain's Stephanie Millward." She won the silver medal in the 100m butterfly in 2008 Beijing Paralympic Games.
From the Wikipedia article:
" At two years of age she was diagnosed with a rare tumour, a sarcoma that was wrapped around the nerves of her right leg.[3]After unsuccessful attempts to treat her cancer with chemotherapy, her right leg was amputated above the knee on 14 February 1994.[6] Eight weeks after the surgery, as part of her rehabilitation, Cole's mother Jenny enrolled her in swimming lessons at the Kings Swimming Club in Mornington. The instructors expected Cole to take about a year to learn how to swim in a straight line, but it took her two weeks."
I met her parents a couple of times. They are good hardworking middle class Australians who spend part of their time and money in social work.
P.S. A recent interview with Ellie Cole http://www.theage.com.au/sport/energy-in-the-pool-to-make-a-difference-20120908-25lev.html

Friday, August 31, 2012

From science blogs

Carl Zimmer on using evolution to evolve drugs, one study uses the fact that humans and yeast share a common ancestor.
Carl Zimmer links to a post on the power of replication.
I do not believe this study. More discussion in Eat Smarter, don't work harder?
Discussion of whether eating before going to bed is bad at Askscience
"but only 1 of my nostrils was plugged up, while the other one was easy breathing as usual. Why does that happen sometimes? " again at Askscience and many more at the same site.

Gorgeous dances by Padmini

from the film Pardesi/Travels Beyond Three Seas. The dances are also available in the second part 0f the film uploaded by Mosfilms here around 10 and 30 minutes (the link sent to me by Minai). The first part here. From the New York Times review
"Unfortunately, the first (Russian) half lumbers along like an elephant, as Mr. Strizhenov restlessly leaves home and tackles various dangers head-on. This portion is clogged with a lot of bearded raving and ranting (not his) and some dreadful ensemble acting. Meanwhile, sliding past are some striking outdoor panoramas of the Volga country, various deserts and seaports.
But the picture is more persuasive, and relaxed, when the hero arrives at his destination and visits Nargis' peasant family during a monsoon. The backgrounds of this pleasant, rather idyllic interlude are beautifully tinted and the mood is happy and serene. And, as we say, Nargis, who leads a chorus in one delightful native song, is a doll. Why the hero leaps on his horse and bolts for home mystifies us. Anyway, the Russians, not the Indians, have the last word."
There is a longer review with many comments at Dustedoff
"What I liked about this film:
Padmini. I must confess I’m not much of a Padmini fan, but in this, she’s wonderful. She’s grace, she’s beauty, she’s allure. Her dancing is fabulous, too—watch this fascinating performancewhere, just by gestures, she says a lot."
The link mentioned does not work but I think that the author is referring to the first dance.
The film also figures in discussions in the blogs of Minai and Richard.

Budaraju Radhakrishna's ''Telugu sangatulu'

కినిగె వాళ్ళు బూదరాజు రాధాక్రిష్న గారి 'తెలుగుసంగతు'లు మళ్ళీ
ప్రచురించారు. ఇంతవరకు చదవని వారికి ఉపయోగపడవచ్చు
http://kinige.com/kbook.php?id=603&name=Telugu+Sangatulu

Thursday, August 30, 2012

Joep Bor's article "Mamia,,Ammani...."

is mostly available at google books except for the pictures. It is a brilliant article, in part based on the experiences of Jacob Haafner. It is also included in the collection of essays Bharatanatyam :A Reader, edited by Davesh Soneji.

Reviews of some books on big questions

I am suspiocious of books about big questions and read only one of the books mentioned below.
 Mike Beggs' reviews of Debt by David Graeber A sample passage:
"The mint can print any numbers on its bills and coins, but cannot decide what those numbers refer to. That is determined by countless price-setting decisions by mainly private firms, reacting strategically to the structure of costs and demand they face, in competition with other firms. Graeber interprets Aristotle as saying that all money is merely “a social convention,” like “worthless bronze coins that we agree to treat as if they were worth a certain amount.” Money is, of course, a social phenomenon. What else would it be? But to call its value a social convention seems to misrepresent the processes by which this value is established in an economy like ours – not by general agreement or political will, but as the outcome of countless interlocking strategies in a vast, decentralized, competitive system."

There is more discussion of the review at Crooked Timber

Gulzar Natarajan discusses "Why Nations Fail" "The search for that magic pill which can explain economic development and national economic growth has a long history of failures."

An overview in Nature of Peter Turchin Human Cycles: History as Science via a post of Razib Khan. Razib Khan has reviewed earlier some of Peter Turchin's books.Razib Khan's readable review of "War and Peace and War: The Rise and Fall of Empires" is here. Of the three cycles (abasiya cycles, secular cycles, fathers-and-sons cycles) discussed by Turchin , Razib says "The other two dynamics are much simpler to understand. For secular cycles Turchin presents some simple phenomenon which occur in many societies

1) Elites overproduce and become top-heavy during times of plenty
2) Inequality in material wealth lead to resentment and social discord

The metastable situation will generally shift at some point and switch to rebellion and civil war. This tends to kill off much of the elite, and naturally redistribute wealth with the collapse of law and order. Obviously there's much more, but that's the gist of it. "
From The Nature article "the fathers-and-sons cycle: the father responds violently to a perceived social injustice; the son lives with the miserable legacy of the resulting conflict and abstains; the third generation begins again. Turchin likens this cycle to a forest fire that ignites and burns out, until a sufficient amount of underbrush accumulates and the cycle recommences."
Apparently, Turchin predicts "He has analysed historical records on economic activity, demographic trends and outbursts of violence in the United States, and has come to the conclusion that a new wave of internal strife is already on its way1. The peak should occur in about 2020, he says, and will probably be at least as high as the one in around 1970. “I hope it won't be as bad as 1870,” he adds."

Somewhat different from the above theories. Hartosh Singh Bal on "Arundhati Roy's Magic Realism"