Thursday, May 18, 2017

Noah Smith on vast literatures

Vast literatures as mud moats "I don't know why academic literatures are so often referred to as "vast" (the phrase goes back well over a century), but it seems like no matter what topic you talk about, someone is always popping up to inform you that there is a "vast literature" on the topic already. This often serves to shut down debate, because it amounts to a demand that before you talk about something, you need to go read voluminous amounts of what others have already written about it. Since vast literatures take many, many hours to read, this represents a significant demand of time and effort. If the vast literature comprises 40 papers, each of which takes an hour to read, that's one week of full-time work equivalent that people are demanding as a cost of entry just to participate in a debate! So the question is: Is it worth it?"
Paul Krugman respond https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2017/05/17/calling-literatures-from-the-vasty-deep/?_r=1 

No comments: